By remaining on the Site or clicking “OK,” you consent to Zazzle’s Terms of Use and Privacy Notice, and to Zazzle’s use of cookies and similar technologies (including those provided by third parties), which retain information to enable the Zazzle experience, track interactions, advertise, and for other related purposes. You may opt-out of this tracking by updating your cookies preferences.

Save 25% on Select Cards & Invitations * Shop Now ➞

Love It or We'll Take Back! Extended Returns Until January 2026 *

Search for products or designs

Sell on Zazzle쑢Shopping Cart

ChristmasOpens a menu with links to top christmas pages

Christmas Cards >
Flat Cards
Foil Cards
Folded Cards
Funny Cards
Non-Photo Cards
Seasonal Cards >
Hanukkah Cards
New Year's Cards
Addressing Service >
Return Address Labels
Envelopes
Christmas Home Decor >
Tree Decorations
Mugs
Cushions
Blankets
Tree Skirts
Stockings
Festive Outfits >
T-shirts
Socks
Totes
Gifts >
Gifts for Him
Gifts for Her
Gifts for Parents
Gifts for Grandparents
Photo Gifts
Funny Gifts
Baby's First Christmas
Create Your Own
Gift Wrapping Supplies >
Wrapping Paper
Stickers
Rubber Stamps
Gift Tags
Party Supplies >
Christmas Party Invitations
New Years Invitations
Napkins
Plates
Barware More for Holidays
Gift Cards

Shop Christmas

Christmas your way.
Shop Christmas at Zazzle.

WeddingsOpens a menu with links to top wedding-related pages.

Invitations & Stationery >
Wedding Invitations
Save the Dates
Enclosure Cards
Rehearsal Dinner Invitations
RSVP Cards
Thank You Cards
Wedding Announcements
Stag Party Invitations
Hens Party Invitations
Bridal Shower Invitations
Mailing Accessories
Envelopes
Décor & Party Supplies >
Posters & Prints
Seating Charts
Banners
Wedding Tabletop Signs
Napkins
Table Serving & Décor
Bucks Party Supplies
Hens Party Supplies
Bridal Shower Supplies
Guest Books
Menus
Programs
Favours >
Wedding Can Coolers
Wedding Magnets
Wedding Sunglasses
Packaging >
Stickers & Labels
Favour Tags
Wine Bottle Labels
Gifts >
Wedding Party Gifts
Newlywed Gifts
Anniversary Gifts
Games & Activities >
Playing Cards
Poker Chips
Wedding Themes
Boho Weddings
Retro Weddings
Minimalist Weddings
Classic Weddings
Rustic Weddings
Floral Weddings
Shop Weddings >

Your wedding, our expertise
Shop Weddings at Zazzle.

Create Your OwnOpens a menu with links to top Create-Your-Own products.

Accessories >
Badges
Tote Bags
Key Rings
Baby & Kids >
Baby Clothes
Wall Art & Décor
Clothing & Shoes >
T-Shirts
Hoodies & Sweatshirts
Socks
Crafts & Party Supplies >
Paper Napkins
Party Signs & Banners
Stickers
Wrapping Paper
Electronics >
Phone Cases
Mouse Pads & Desk Mats
Office & School >
Business Cards
ID Badges
Post-it® Notes
Home Décor >
Cushions
Blankets
Outdoor Signs & Flags
Mugs
Aprons
Sports, Toys, & Games >
Pickleball Paddles
Golf Balls
Puzzles
Wall Art & Decor >
Posters
Canvas Prints
Photo Tiles
Invitations & Stationery >
Save the Dates
Greeting Cards
Return Address Labels

Weddings >
Programs
Menus
Guest Books
Create Your Own >

Create Your Own
Create something perfectly one-of-a-kind.

Gifts & OccasionsOpens a menu with links to top gift and moment-related pages.

Gifts for Everyone
Gifts for Him
Gifts for Her
Gifts for Parents
Gifts for Grandparents
Gifts for Kids
Gifts for Teens
Funny Gifts
Photo Gifts
Gifts Under $50
Gifts Under $25
Shop Gifts >
Officially Licensed Stores
Warner Bros.
DC™
Sesame Street™
Peanuts
Wizarding World™
Dr. Seuss™
Afro Unicorn
Looney Tunes™
Miraculous
Official Stores >
All of Life's Moments
Birthdays
Baby Showers
Weddings
Graduation
Mother's Day
Top Gift Ideas
T-Shirts
Mugs
Cushions
Blankets
Aprons
More on Zazzle
New Arrivals
Shop the Sale
Trending Creators

Personalised Gifts
Ideas for everyone on your list.

Invitations & StationeryOpens a menu with links to top invitations & stationery-related pages.

Invitations & Announcements >
Wedding Invitations
Baby Shower Invitations
Birthday Invitations
RSVP Cards
Save the Dates
Graduation Announcements
Graduation Invitations
Moving Announcements
Religious Invitations
Greeting Cards >
Postcards
Birthday Cards
Thank You Cards
Graduation Cards
Mother's Day Cards
Father's Day Cards
Christmas Cards
Hanukkah Cards
Mailing Accessories >
Envelope Seals
Envelopes
Invitation Belly Bands
Return Address Labels
Rubber Stamps & Ink
Personalised Stationery >
Note Cards
Notepads
Post-it® Notes
Stationery Paper
Invitations & Stationery >

Invitations & Stationery
Great cards, invites, and mailing accessories to make your day.

Office & SchoolOpens a menu with links to top office & school-related pages.

Business Cards >
QR Code Business Cards
Hair Stylist Business Cards
Construction Business Cards
Office & School Supplies >
Calendars
Planners
Desk Accessories
ID Badges
Name Tags
Business Stationery >
Appointment Cards
Notebooks
Notepads
Rubber Stamps & Ink
Displays & Packaging >
Display Cards
Hang Tags & Package Inserts
Price Tags
Product Labels
Marketing Materials >
Flyers
Gift Certificates
Loyalty Cards
Referral Cards
Discount Cards
Promotional Products
Menus & Price Lists
Bumper Stickers & Magnets
Signs & Posters >
Banners
Posters & Prints

Office & School >

Office & School
Explore perfectly custom office and school supplies.

Crafts & Party SuppliesOpens a menu with links to top crafts & party supplies-related pages.

Craft Supplies >
Scrapbook Albums
Rubber Stamps & Ink
Scrapbook Paper
Bookplates & Labels
Gift Wrapping Supplies >
Gift Boxes
Gift Tags
Ribbon
Stickers & Labels
Tissue Paper
Wrapping Paper
Décor >
Backdrops
Balloons
Confetti
Party Signs
Banners
Posters & Prints
Favours >
Hand Fans
Games & Activities >
Beer Pong Tables
Playing Cards
Packaging >
Favour Bags
Favour Boxes
Favour Tags
Stationery >
Guest Books
Place Cards
Tableware >
Bottle Tags
Paper Napkins
Paper & Party Plates
Paper Bowls
Paper Cups
Paper Placemats
Wine Glass Charms & Tags
Crafts & Party >

Crafts & Party Supplies
Celebrate everything with custom party decorations and more.

MoreOpens a menu with links to more categories of top pages.

Clothing & Shoes >
T-Shirts & Shirts
Hoodies & Sweatshirts
Socks
Shoes
Leggings
Baby & Kids >
Kids Clothing
Toddler Clothing
Baby Clothing
Clothing Labels
Accessories >
Badges
Key Rings
Hats
Suit Accessories
Travel Accessories
Bags & Wallets >
Tote Bags
Backpacks
Bum Bags
Gym & Duffel Bags
Electronics >
Phone Cases & Accessories
Mouse Pads & Desk Mats

Sports & Outdoor Gear >
Game Room
Golf Accessories & Golf Gear
Pickleball Paddles
Toys & Games >
Playing Cards
Puzzles
Wall Art & Décor >
Posters & Prints
Canvas Art
Wall Art Sets
Clocks
Tapestries
Wall Decals & Stickers
Wallpaper
Nursery & Kids' Room Décor >
Blankets
Door Signs
Nursery Art
Shop All >

쎃

쎃

Popular Pilgrim Jigsaw Puzzles

67 results

All Products

< Sports, Toys & Games

< Toys & Games

110

252

520

676

1014

Standard

Oversized

$25 to $50

$50 to $75

$75 to $100

Over $100

20.3 cm x 25.4 cm

27.9 cm x 35.6 cm

50.8 cm x 76.2 cm

40.6 cm x 50.8 cm

50.8 cm x 50.8 cm

Vertical

Horizontal

Bridgeman Images...

Number of Puzzle Pieces

Puzzle Piece Size

Price

Size

Design Style

Shape

Orientation

Officially Licensed

Special Picks

Events & Occasions

Recipients

Brand

Creator Store

Makers

Design Options

Number of Photos

Design Colour

Sort by:

The First Thanksgiving at Plymouth by Brownscombe Jigsaw Puzzle

Price$37.05

Camino Santiago St Jacques James Travel Poster Jigsaw Puzzle

Price$44.05

Turkey Gobble Gobble Jigsaw Puzzle

Price$33.20

first thanksgiving jigsaw puzzle

Price$35.05

Pilgrim's Thanksgiving of 1620 Jigsaw Puzzle

Price$39.40

Thankgiving Joy puzzle

Price$35.05

The First Thanksgiving Jigsaw Puzzle

Price$39.40

Still can't find what you're looking for?

Search Feedback

Did you find what you were looking for?

YesNo

If you need help or have a question for Customer Service, please visit our Help Centre