By remaining on the Site or clicking “OK,” you consent to Zazzle’s Terms of Use and Privacy Notice, and to Zazzle’s use of cookies and similar technologies (including those provided by third parties), which retain information to enable the Zazzle experience, track interactions, advertise, and for other related purposes. You may opt-out of this tracking by updating your cookies preferences.

Seasonal Deals Save up to 40% on Christmas Cards* Shop Now ➞

Save 15% to 30% on Bestsellers* Shop Now ➞

Search for products or designs

Christmas

Christmas Cards ➞
Flat Cards
Folded Cards
Foil Cards
Funny Cards
Non-Photo Cards
New Year's Cards
Mailing Accessories ➞
Return Address Labels
Envelopes
Christmas Home Decor ➞
Tree Decorations
Mugs
Cushions
Blankets
Aprons
Tree Skirts
Stockings
Festive Outfits ➞
T-Shirts
Ties
Socks
Totes
Gift Wrapping ➞
Wrapping Paper
Stickers
Rubber Stamps
Gift Tags

Party Supplies ➞
Christmas Party Invitations
New Year's Eve Invitations
Napkins
Plates
Cups
Barware
Gifts ➞
Gifts for Him
Gifts for Her
Photo Gifts
Funny Gifts
Baby's First Christmas
Create Your Own

Gift Cards ➞

Shop Christmas ➞

The Christmas Shop
Create cards, gifts, decor, and more on Zazzle.

WeddingsOpens a menu with links to top wedding-related pages.

Wedding Invitations ➞
Wedding Stationery ➞
Be My Bridesmaid Cards
Bridal Shower Invites
Enclosure Cards
Engagement Party Invites
Hens Party Invitations
Reception Invites
RSVP Cards
Save the Dates
Thank You Cards
Wedding Décor ➞
Guest Books
Menus
Napkins
Place Cards
Plates
Programs
Seating Charts
Wedding Signs
Table Numbers
Favour Packaging ➞
Beer Labels
Can Coolers
Favour Bags
Favour Tags
Magnets
Stickers & Labels
Water Labels
Wine Bottle Labels
Showers & Parties ➞
Bridal Shower Supplies
Hens Party Supplies
Wedding Gifts ➞
Bridesmaid Gifts
Groomsmen Gifts

All Weddings ➞

Wedding Stationery & Décor
From save the dates to signage, design every detail of your day.

Invitations & StationeryOpens a menu with links to top invitations & stationery-related pages.

Birthday Invitations ➞
Kids' Birthday Invitations
Adult Birthday Invitations
Joint Birthday Invitations
1st Birthday Invitations

Baby Invitations ➞
Baby Shower Invitations
Birth Announcements
More Invitations ➞
Christening Invitations
Christmas Invitations
Communion Invitations
Graduation Invitations
Halloween Invitations
Moving Announcements
Party Invitations
Greeting Cards ➞
Anniversary Cards
Birthday Cards
Christmas Cards
Father's Day Cards
Graduation Cards
Mother's Day Cards
New Baby Cards
Thank You Cards
Valentine's Cards
Personal Stationery ➞
Note Cards
Postcards
Post-it® Notes

Mailing Accessories ➞
Envelopes
Envelope Seals
Return Address Labels
Rubber Stamps & Ink

All Invitations & Stationery ➞

Cards & Invitations 
Personalise premium stationery for any event or milestone.

Gift Wrap & Party SuppliesOpens a menu with links to top crafts & party supplies-related pages.

Gift Wrapping ➞
Gift Bags
Gift Tags
Ribbon
Stickers & Labels
Tissue Paper
Wrapping Paper
Party Signs ➞
Backdrops
Banners
Posters & Prints
Party Stationery ➞
Guest Books
Menus
Place Cards
Programs
Table Numbers
Party Tableware ➞
Paper Cups
Paper Bowls
Paper Napkins
Paper Plates
Favours & Packaging ➞
Can Coolers
Favour Bags
Favour Boxes
Favour Tags
Food & Drink Labels

All Gift Wrap & Party ➞

Gift Wrap & Party Supplies
Make their day with personalised wrapping & party decorations.

Office & SchoolOpens a menu with links to top office & school-related pages.

Business Cards ➞
Bakery Business Cards
Beauty Business Cards
Construction Business Cards
DJ Business Cards
Hair Stylist Business Cards
QR Code Business Cards
Name Tags & Badges ➞
Marketing Materials ➞
Appointment Cards
Brochures
Flyers
Gift Certificates
Loyalty Cards
Menus & Price Lists
Referral Cards
Displays & Packaging ➞
Display Cards
Hang Tags & Inserts
Product Labels

Business Stationery ➞
Notebooks
Post-it® Notes
Rubber Stamps & Ink
Business Signs ➞
Banners
Posters & Prints
Window Decals

Calendars ➞

All Business ➞

Business Essentials
Boost your brand with quality business cards & marketing materials.

Art & HomeOpens a menu with links to more categories of top pages.

Mugs ➞
Funny Mugs
Photo Mugs

Barware ➞
Beer Glasses
Can Coolers
Shot Glasses
Whiskey Glasses
Wine Glasses
More Homeware ➞
Aprons
Blankets
Christmas Tree Decorations
Cushions
Posters & Prints ➞
Abstract Posters
Botanical Posters
Fine Art Posters
Nursery Posters
Travel Posters
Vintage Posters

Art & Home 
Style your space with personalised posters, cushions, mugs & more.

T-Shirts & Accessories

T-Shirts ➞
Men's T-Shirts
Women's T-Shirts

Birthday T-Shirts
Funny T-Shirts
Photo T-Shirts
Vintage T-Shirts
Wedding T-Shirts
Accessories ➞
Badges
Beach Towels
Hats
Luggage Tags
Socks
Ties
Tote Bags
Sports & Games ➞
Golf Balls
Playing Cards
Puzzles

T-Shirts, Tote Bags & More
From business to birthdays to bridal showers, customise items for any occasion.

Create Your OwnOpens a menu with links to top Create-Your-Own products.

T-Shirts & Accessories
Badges
Hats
Socks
Ties
Tote Bags
T-Shirts

Sports & Games
Golf Balls
Playing Cards
Puzzles
Art & Home
Aprons
Blankets
Christmas Tree Decorations
Cushions
Mugs
Posters
Gift Wrap & Party
Paper Napkins
Party Signs
Stickers
Wrapping Paper
Business
Business Cards
Flyers
ID Badges
Post-it® Notes
Invitations & Stationery
Greeting Cards
Guest Books
Invitations
Menus
Programs
Return Address Labels
Rubber Stamps
Save the Dates

All Create Your Own ➞

Create Your Own
Make your own mugs, t-shirts & more with our easy design tool.

Popular First Tooth Crafts & Party Supplies

157 results

Crafts & Party Supplies

All Products

Craft Supplies

Gift Wrapping Supplies

Party Supplies

Under $5

$5 to $15

$15 to $25

$25 to $50

$50 to $75

$75 to $100

Over $100

Price

Design Style

Special Picks

Events & Occasions

Recipients

Creator Store

Makers

Design Options

Colour

Number of Photos

Design Colour

Sort by:

Save 15%

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Square Sticker

Sale Price $18.92.$18.92 Original Price $22.25.$22.25

Save 15%

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Wrapping Paper

Sale Price $57.93.$57.93 Original Price $68.15.$68.15

Save 15%

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Paper Plate

Sale Price $4.42.$4.42 Original Price $5.20.$5.20

Save 15%

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Tags

Sale Price $19.60.$19.60 Original Price $23.05.$23.05

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Large Gift Bag

Price$24.70

Save 15%

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Favour Tags

Sale Price $25.12.$25.12 Original Price $29.55.$29.55

I Lost My First Tooth Teeth Out Kids Gift Tissue Paper

Price$11.35

Save 15%

First Tooth and Stars Paper Napkin

Sale Price $61.50.$61.50 Original Price $72.35.$72.35

Save 15%

Tilly the Snail with Polkadots Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $14.96.$14.96 Original Price $17.60.$17.60

Save 15%

iBrush Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $18.79.$18.79 Original Price $22.10.$22.10

Save 15%

Tooth Fairy pink white party decor. Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.91.$3.91 Original Price $4.60.$4.60

Save 15%

Agra Hadig - First tooth Pink bow Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $16.15.$16.15 Original Price $19.00.$19.00

Collection

First Tooth Double-sided Scrapbooking paper

Price$4.12

First Tooth Double-sided Scrapbooking paper

Price$4.12

First Tooth Baby Girl Scrapbooking paper

Price$4.12

Save 15%

Tooth Fairy Poem Kids Personalised Label

Sale Price $15.77.$15.77 Original Price $18.55.$18.55

First Tooth Baby Boy Scrapbooking paper

Price$4.12

Save 15%

Funny Tooth Fairy - Cute Unicorn I Lost My First T Gift Tags

Sale Price $22.61.$22.61 Original Price $26.60.$26.60

First Tooth Baby Girl Scrapbooking paper

Price$4.12

Baby Girl First Tooth Shower Scrapbooking paper

Price$4.12

Save 15%

My First Cavity Tooth Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $15.77.$15.77 Original Price $18.55.$18.55

Save 15%

Scary Halloween One Tooth Pumpkin Square Sticker

Sale Price $16.66.$16.66 Original Price $19.60.$19.60

Save 15%

Funny Tooth Fairy - Cute Unicorn I Lost My First T Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $25.80.$25.80 Original Price $30.35.$30.35

Save 15%

I got my first tooth Baby Boy Teething Date Squar Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.74.$3.74 Original Price $4.40.$4.40

Save 15%

Funny Tooth Fairy - Cute Unicorn I Lost My First T Paper Plate

Sale Price $6.04.$6.04 Original Price $7.10.$7.10

Save 15%

Funny Tooth Fairy - Cute Unicorn I Lost My First T Heart Sticker

Sale Price $26.78.$26.78 Original Price $31.50.$31.50

Kids Find 2 Same Pictures Tooth Fairy Small Gift

Price$3.51

Save 15%

Agra Hadig- Armenian letters tooth celebration Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $16.15.$16.15 Original Price $19.00.$19.00

Collection

Word Search Puzzle. First Tooth Party Game

Price$4.14

Kids Find 2 Same Pictures First Tooth Party Game.

Price$4.14

Kids Find Shadow Puzzle. First Tooth Party Game.

Price$4.14

Save 15%

Make a Change with a Cup of Coffee Sunshine Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $19.17.$19.17 Original Price $22.55.$22.55

Save 15%

Reading Is A Ticket To Adventure Elementary Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $19.17.$19.17 Original Price $22.55.$22.55

Save 15%

Happy First Day Of 6th Grade Teacher Student Back Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $19.17.$19.17 Original Price $22.55.$22.55

My First Tooth Party Decorations Bunting Flags

Price$51.30

Agra Hadig-Blue Armenian letters Bunting

Price$52.75

Collection

First Tooth-Armenian Letters Blue Favour Box

Price$5.40

Collection

Save 15%

Agra Hadig-Armenian First tooth Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.79.$3.79 Original Price $4.45.$4.45

Collection

Save 15%

Agra Hadig Blue First Tooth Celebration Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.96.$3.96 Original Price $4.65.$4.65

Collection

First Tooth Party Decor Favour Box

Price$5.00

Save 15%

First Tooth Pink Paper Napkin

Sale Price $61.50.$61.50 Original Price $72.35.$72.35

I got my First Tooth party decoration. Banner

Price$128.00

First Tooth Party Favour Box

Price$5.00

Save 15%

Pink First Tooth Minimalist Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.96.$3.96 Original Price $4.65.$4.65

Collection

Save 15%

Agra Hadig Pink First Tooth Minimalist Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.96.$3.96 Original Price $4.65.$4.65

Collection

Save 15%

Agra Hadig Pink Bow First Tooth Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.96.$3.96 Original Price $4.65.$4.65

Collection

Save 15%

3 14 Pi Mathematics Physics Irrational Number Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $19.17.$19.17 Original Price $22.55.$22.55

First Tooth party bunting banner

Price$48.85

I got my First Tooth Party Banner

Price$116.00

My First Tooth Party Decoration Pink Bunting Flags

Price$51.30

Save 15%

First Tooth party decoration. For baby boy. Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $16.32.$16.32 Original Price $19.20.$19.20

Save 15%

Crying cartoon baby classic round sticker

Sale Price $21.85.$21.85 Original Price $25.70.$25.70

Save 15%

My First Tooth Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $16.66.$16.66 Original Price $19.60.$19.60

Save 15%

First Tooth party paper plate

Sale Price $3.49.$3.49 Original Price $4.10.$4.10

Save 15%

First Tooth Party Girly Pink Decorative Sticker

Sale Price $15.56.$15.56 Original Price $18.30.$18.30

Save 15%

Agra Hadig - First tooth with Name Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $16.15.$16.15 Original Price $19.00.$19.00

Collection

I got my First Tooth baby girl party decoration. Banner

Price$128.00

Save 15%

First Tooth party decor. Paper Plate

Sale Price $3.49.$3.49 Original Price $4.10.$4.10

Save 15%

Kid's Lost First Tooth Congratulations Milestone Classic Round Sticker

Sale Price $15.77.$15.77 Original Price $18.55.$18.55

Save 15%

Custom Baby Girl Tooth Fairy Sticker

Sale Price $14.96.$14.96 Original Price $17.60.$17.60

쎂Previous 1 2 3 Next쎃

Search Feedback

Did you find what you were looking for?

YesNo

If you need help or have a question for Customer Service, please visit our Help Centre

Yes! Send me exclusive offers, unique gift ideas, and personalised tips on Zazzle

Need inspo?

Gift Guides
New Arrivals
Top Deals
Officially Licensed
Creators

About

Company info
Press

Help

Help Centre
My Account
Track my order
Return Policy
Sitemap

Sell

Sell on Zazzle
Ambassador Program
Community forum

Our Platform

Blog

User Agreement
Privacy Notice